The 2022/23 football season had one of the best individual campaigns in the history of the sport. A young Norwegian striker came to England and broke scoring records right away, dominated defenses, and led his team to a historic treble. But when the votes were counted for football’s most important individual award, the winner was someone else.
The argument that came after has not gone away. Many fans, pundits, and analysts continue to ask whether Erling Haaland was unfairly denied the ballon d’or after his historic season with Manchester city in the premier league.
As soon as Erling Haaland stepped onto the field in England, he looked like a player who could set records. Manchester City signed him in the summer of 2022, and fans had high hopes for him. However, even the most optimistic fans could not have predicted how big of an impact he would have.
Within months, he had turned the premier league into his personal playground, scoring goals with ruthless efficiency and redefining what dominance from a striker looked like in the modern game.
His performances made him one of the most talked-about football players in the world right away. The main point of contention in the 2023 ballon d’or vote is the comparison between Erling Haaland and Lionel Messi.
Messi led Argentina to World Cup victory in Qatar, which was a very important event in history. But fans of Erling Haaland say that the award usually goes to the best player over the course of a club season, and by that measure, the Norwegian striker’s stats and accomplishments with Manchester City were almost unbeatable in modern football history.
To fully understand the argument, we need to look at what Erling Haaland really did during the 2022/23 season. Just the numbers tell a great story. He broke the long-standing record for most goals in a single season in his first season in the Premier League.
Defenders had a hard time dealing with his speed, strength, and strange ability to find space in the penalty area week after week. The striker finished the league campaign with a tally that placed him well ahead of other elite football players competing for the Golden Boot.
Erling Haaland’s dominance didn’t end with league play in his home country. He was just as deadly in European competitions. His goals helped Manchester City get through the knockout rounds of the Champions League, where they won the trophy for the first time in their history.
The club made history by winning the Champions League, the Premier League, and the FA Cup all at the same time. It was the result of years of investment and strategic planning by Pep Guardiola, with Erling Haaland playing a key role in that success.
One of the reasons the debate around the ballon d’or became so intense was the sheer scale of Haaland’s goal-scoring numbers.
Image Credit: GettyImage
Erling Haaland scored hat tricks with amazing regularity during the season. He scored five goals in one Champions League game against RB Leipzig, showing not only how efficient he is, but also how precise he is in front of goal. Many people thought that Erling Haaland was changing the way modern strikers play after seeing performances like that.
However, those who disagree with the idea that Erling Haaland should have won the Ballon d’Or often talk about how he fit into Guardiola’s system. Some analysts say that Manchester City’s tactical dominance helped him score goals by giving him a steady stream of chances from teammates like Kevin De Bruyne.
This view says that Haaland had one of the most creative midfields in football history, while players like Messi had to be more creative for their teams. People who like Erling Haaland strongly disagree with this argument.
They say that elite finishing is an amazing skill on its own and that consistently scoring goals at the highest level requires a level of calmness, positioning, and physical intelligence that most football players don’t have.
Erling Haaland scored more goals in 2022/23 than many other legendary strikers who played on talented teams. The historical importance of the treble is another important part of the conversation. Only a few teams have ever won the Champions League, Premier League, and FA Cup in the same season.
Manchester city joined an exclusive group that includes some of the greatest teams in football history. Many people think that Erling Haaland should have won the Ballon d’Or because he was the team’s main goal scorer.
The award itself has changed over time, and people have often disagreed about what should be required to win it. The ballon d’or has always been given to the best player in world football, but the meaning of “best” has changed over time.
Some years focus on how well a team does in statistics, while others focus on historic achievements like winning the World Cup. The World Cup had a big impact on how people thought in 2023. The World Cup win was the last piece of the puzzle for Lionel Messi’s amazing career.
Many fans thought that this tournament made him one of the best football players of all time. Because the World Cup only happens once every four years, it often has a huge impact on awards voting because of how emotional it is.
That context explains why many journalists and national team coaches favored Messi despite the club-level achievements of Erling Haaland. The argument continues, though, because the numbers are still clear.
Erling Haaland scored more than 50 goals in all of his games during the 2022/23 season. That many goals made him one of the best goal scorers in the history of European club football. He was one of the most feared forwards in the world because he could score with either foot, win aerial duels, and break past defenders.
Erling Haaland’s performances were even more impressive because he quickly got used to playing in England. Many people think that the Premier League is one of the hardest sports competitions on the body. It can take months or even years for many world-class football players to get used to its speed and intensity.
Haaland, on the other hand, took control almost right away. In addition to his physical attributes, Erling Haaland displayed remarkable tactical awareness throughout the season.
Guardiola’s system depends a lot on players staying in their positions and moving together. Haaland had only been with the team for a few months, but he learned how to time his runs perfectly, which stretched the defense and made room for his teammates.
This flexibility let Manchester City change its tactics while still being able to attack quickly. Another point that Erling Haaland’s supporters often make is that the story behind an award can affect how people vote.
The story of Messi finally winning the World Cup was very moving and well-known. Haaland’s story, on the other hand, was mostly about his team’s success and his own statistical dominance. Some analysts think that the story behind the vote for the Ballon d’Or had more of an effect on the outcome than the players’ actual performance on the field.
The impact of media attention also contributes to the formation of perceptions regarding individual accomplishments. Throughout the season, the goal-scoring exploits of Erling Haaland dominated headlines across Europe.
It seemed like every week brought a new record or milestone. But when voters chose the Ballon d’Or, the World Cup story overshadowed a lot of the club season. The debate also shows how hard it is to compare different kinds of excellence in football as a whole.
A creative playmaker and a striker who scores goals help the game in very different ways. Messi set up attacks and had moments of brilliance for Argentina, while Erling Haaland scored goals for Manchester City all the time.
It is always subjective to decide which contribution is more valuable. Even though there was a lot of debate about it, a lot of people think that the 2022/23 season was the start of a new era for Erling Haaland.
He was only 23 years old during that campaign, but he already had a goal-scoring record that many great football players only reached in their best years. His speed, strength, and ability to finish suggest that he may be able to do even more amazing things in the future.
Image Credit: Getty Images
From a historical perspective, seasons like the one delivered by Erling Haaland often receive recognition over time even if immediate awards go elsewhere. There are many examples in football history of players whose impact became clearer over time. If Haaland keeps breaking records and winning trophies, the argument over the 2023 Ballon d’Or may end up being a small part of a much bigger story.
Conclusion
In the end, whether Erling Haaland was robbed of the ballon d’or depends on how you define what it means to be great at football. Messi’s win makes sense if the award is based on World Cup accomplishments and moments that change a player’s career.
When you look at club dominance, statistical superiority, and the effect of one season, the case for Haaland becomes very strong. No one can argue that the 2022/23 season made Erling Haaland one of the most famous people in the world.
His performances changed what people thought a striker could do in modern football. Fans saw a rare mix of athletic power and a knack for scoring that reminded many of the best goal scorers in history.
The debate over the Ballon d’Or will probably go on as long as great seasons and historic international achievements happen at the same time. Yet regardless of the outcome of that particular vote, the legacy of Erling Haaland during the 2022/23 campaign remains extraordinary.
His goals helped Manchester City have one of the best seasons in the club’s history. His arrival made the Premier League more competitive and exciting for everyone. In the end, the talk about Erling Haaland and the Ballon d’Or shows how beautiful football is.
The sport does well when people argue, are passionate, and have different points of view. Haaland’s record-breaking season made sure that his name will be at the center of conversations about great football players for many years to come, no matter what people think of him.
People Also Ask About Ballon d’or
- Who deserved the 23 Ballon d’Or?
Lionel Messi won the award for a record-extending eighth time after leading Argentina in their victorious 2022 FIFA World Cup campaign. Thus Messi became the only player in history to win the award with three different clubs (Barcelona, PSG, Inter Miami) and the only one to win it while playing outside Europe.
- Who did Haaland lose the Ballon d’Or to?
Messi pipped Haaland to the prize after World Cup heroics, producing magical performances during the knockout stages.
- Why did Messi beat Haaland?
With Messi and Haaland level on points after the votes were counted, the award ultimately was given to Messi after the Argentina star attracted more first-place nominations from the men’s national team captains than his Norwegian rival.
- Who is Man City’s best striker?
Manchester City’s top striker depends on the context: Sergio Agüero is the all-time leading goalscorer, but Erling Haaland is the current star striker, leading goals in recent seasons (2024-25) and rapidly climbing the all-time charts with incredible goal-scoring rates, becoming the club’s second-highest scorer ever.
Related Articles
The 13 Best English Football Players Ever!
Top 11 Best Football Defenders of All Time
